CYA*

I repeat what I said yesterday:  “The editing of the Benghazi talking points strikes me as unworthy of a news story on an inside page.”  But if you want to understand what happened, here  is as clear an account as I have seen, extracted from the emails the White House made public yesterday:

The best narrative on the Benghazi emails

It is not clear who wrote this, but it was sent to Ambassador Susan Rice at the US mission to the UN on September 15 at 1:23 pm, apparently along with the approved talking points for her to use the next day.  By way of explication, the SVTS is a classified videoconference, Morell was deputy director of the CIA, Rhodes and McDonough were top White House aides.  They deferred to Sullivan at the State Department.

Morell’s “heavy editing hand” shows clearly on the marked up document:

Morrell’s mark-up of the talking points.

It is clear from the other emails that Tori Nuland at State had objected to some of the items excised, but it is also clear that CIA carried the bulk of the drafting and excising responsibility.  This is logical, as the facility in Benghazi was not a normal diplomatic post but principally a CIA facility.  CIA had at least as much reason as State to get rid of references to prior warnings and extremists.  While the White House deferred to State, CIA did the actual excising.

To make a long story short, this was a CYA* editing job, to which Susan Rice appears to have contributed nothing.  She was the unwitting victim of a bureaucratic exercise of no particular interest or merit.  Would it not have been better to spend the time and energy wasted on this issue instead on whether the U.S. should have done more to help establish rule of law in Libya after Qaddafi fell?  Come to think of it, that would still be a good question on which to expend some time and effort.

*For my non-American readers, that’s “cover your ass.”

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

People are not pleased but it will get worse

He wants an America swollen with racial prejudice and isolated from the world. Half the…

20 hours ago

Okay, but still a long way to go

Is this a revival of the 1920s and 1930s America that tried to limit immigration,…

2 days ago

Hope is where the wild things are

Hope lies wherever the restraining and suffocating writ of the Trump Administration does not extend.…

5 days ago

America made a giant mistake

It will take more time for Americans to fathom the mistake they have made. But…

1 week ago

Serbia is going backwards

I received this plea today. The issues are not new but now the situation is…

2 weeks ago

Might doesn’t make right, but it’s winning

Trump can't get anything out of Putin because the American President has already given too…

2 weeks ago