Categories: Daniel Serwer

Netanyahu v Hammond

This is about as good an exchange as you are going to find on the Iran nuclear deal:

From my point of view, it is telling that Netanyahu says absolutely nothing about how multilateral sanctions, international inspections and technological constraints on Iran’s nuclear program would be maintained in the absence of a deal. He simply repeats that he wants maintenance of sanctions and a better deal, one that somehow ends burning of Israeli flags in Tehran as well as other odious Iranian behavior. I’d like a pony too.

Note also: Netanyahu suggests North Korea developed its nuclear weapons while under IAEA monitoring. That is not really true. Pyongyang ejected the inspectors and withdrew from the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) in 2003. It first tested a nuclear weapon in 2006. Of course Iran could also withdraw from the NPT, but the agreement reached this week includes the following sentence:

Iran reaffirms that under no circumstances will Iran ever seek, develop or acquire any nuclear weapons.

You can believe it or not, but it certainly goes beyond previous commitments Iran has made in writing.

I’d score this bout a win for Hammond, but admittedly that is the direction in which I lean. There simply is no good alternative to an agreement. Whether this one is the best we could get or not, it is now the only one available. Netanyahu and other opponents will soon be screeching about the need to implement it to the letter and complaining about every conceivable Iranian deviation.

Daniel Serwer

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

Ukraine doesn’t like Trump’s surrender

a president who is dismantling the US government is doing the same to its alliances…

3 days ago

Part 1: Is this what you voted for?

J. F. Carter, US Army (ret LTC) 1968-1992, United Nations (ret D-1) 1992-2009, and European…

4 days ago

Europe needs to unify and toughen up, fast

Trump is unsympathetic to alliances in general, NATO in particular, and the EU most of…

5 days ago

The America Trump wants is not democratic

Winning enough of those seats to gain a majority in one of the Houses will…

6 days ago

The cabinet of horrors is getting confirmed

This really is a cabinet of horrors. The most unqualified people serving the least serious…

1 week ago

Trump reinvents the Foreign Service wheel

Yes, State needs cutting. But you have to start in the right place. Reinventing the…

1 week ago