Month: January 2021
Georgia points the way, DC, Puerto Rico, and Mississippi next
It is hard to think past yesterday’s attempted putsch at the Capitol, but I really do think the victory of two Democrats in Georgia’s Senate run-off elections is far more significant. The imbalance in the Senate in favor of the Republicans has been a major factor in the radicalization of that party and the rise of Trumpism.
Once the Georgia Democrats are seated, Mitch McConnell, the Grim Reaper, will go into opposition and Chuck Schumer will control the agenda of the upper house. That in itself is important, as it will enable a new corona virus relief bill to be passed, including $2000 relief checks. They may not be the best economic stimulus idea, but the Democrats will still want to deliver them, along with aid to states and small business. I imagine some Republicans will vote in favor in both houses.
But on many things, legislation in the Senate faces what Americans call “the filibuster.” In its current form, this is a rule that requires 60 votes (out of 100) to close debate on a proposal and proceed to vote on it. The filibuster presumably encourages moderation and bipartisanship, though I’d be glad if someone could point me to research that demonstrates that effect. There are already some exceptions to the filibuster, the rules for which are incredibly arcane: budget “reconciliation” and nominations to high office. Eliminating the filibuster entirely is something both parties have hesitated to do when they are in the majority, because they know full well they may some day be in the minority.
I wouldn’t suggest eliminating the filibuster altogether. But I do think another exception should be carved out for admitting states to the Union. It is simply undemocratic to deprive the citizens resident in the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico of representation and power equivalent to that of states that are less populous. Both have held referenda in favor of statehood, The District (which would become the (Frederick) Douglas Commonwealth, thus still DC) would get two senators and a voting representative. It already has the equivalent number (3) of electoral votes. Puerto Rico, whose citizens are already entitled to vote when they are resident in one of the 50 states, would get two senators and five representatives.
These additions to the Congress and the Electoral College would go some distance to eliminating deviations from one person one vote that prevail in the Senate and Electoral College today. The Democratic members of the Senate currently represent more than 40 million more people than the equal number of Republican members. Due to the distribution of Electoral College votes, Trump won the presidency in 2016 with almost 3 million fewer popular votes than Hillary Clinton.
Joe Biden, who spent most of his adult life in the Senate, will not be convinced easily to modify the filibuster. But he might be forced to it by Republican intransigence in the Senate. Admitting DC and Puerto Rico as states would give the Republican party strong incentives to abandon Trumpism and turn back towards a more moderate political course. That is precisely what is needed: a Yougov quick poll yesterday showed 45% of Republicans supported the storming of the Congress. Only defeat at the polls and in Congress will lower that number.
More Democratic senators are also possible without admitting new states. Mississippi, which recently erased a Confederate symbol from its state flag, is close to 38% black. If they turn out to vote, as Georgia’s black population did, Mississippi too could become a purple or even blue state. Louisiana and South Carolina also have higher black populations than Georgia. One of the big fights in the next few years will therefore be over voting rights and procedures. The epidemic enabled a lot of people to vote by mail in states that otherwise discourage their participation, including Georgia. That is the right direction.
Stevenson’s army, January 7
Say a prayer for American democracy. It has been badly wounded.
NYT has the trail of incitements to treason.
Former APSA Congressional Fellow Paul Musgrave explains why it can be called an attempted coup.
Politico reporters describe the scary events.
The rioters justified themselves.
The Capitol Police underestimated the threat and responded incompetently. Heads will roll.
General Mattis finally speaks out
Ezra Klein has a fine first column at NYT..
PUTSCH! It will fail, but it is a bad omen
Pro-Trump extremists stormed the Capitol today and halted the constitutional process of confirming the Electoral College votes. The President encouraged this violent attack on the transition of power. Capitol Police seem to have been lamentably unprepared, despite weeks of advance notice. They did little to stop the assault. You can imagine what would have happened had they been chanting “Black Lives Matter.”
The proper response is for the Congress to meet in an alternate location this evening and quickly accept the electoral result. The House should re-impeach President Trump tomorrow and the Senate vote to remove him from office. Vice President Pence should be sworn in to finish out Trump’s term while he is arrested for inciting violence.
None of my daydream will happen, because the Republicans won’t be on board and the Democrats will hesitate. A dozen Republican Senators had already loudly pledged to object to the certification of the electoral votes. They too are morally responsible for the deplorable behavior of the rioters, who are virtually all white and male.
So I’ll offer a more realistic scenario. The Congress should meet tomorrow to complete the certification of the electoral votes. As soon as the two new Democratic Georgia Senators are able to take their seats, the Congress should pass a corona virus bill providing $2000 relief payments to less well off Americans and financing for the states to accelerate Covid19 testing and vaccinations as well as reopening of schools and support for small businesses. Biden should sign it on January 20.
Congress should also vote to admit Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia (to be known as the Douglas Commonwealth) as states. This would enfranchise their more or less 3.8 million citizens and ensure a majority in both Houses that supports the constitution for the foreseeable future, or at least until the Republican party figures out it will need to appeal more broadly in order to regain power.
Whether that all happens or not, the putsch will fail. But it should never have happened and bodes ill for the future. Trump has managed to convince a significant part of the population that they have good reason to object to the electoral outcome, despite the failure to produce any evidence of electoral fraud, his loss of 62 court cases, and the illogic of asserting that the Democrats somehow stole the presidency but neglected to steal more House and Senate seats.
None of that matters because the real cause of the resentment lies elsewhere. Trump’s diehard supporters resent losing power to people they think are not their equals, because they are black, immigrants, women, gays, socialists, communists, and other unworthies. White supremacy is not just about people saying they are superior because they are white. It’s about supposing that you are the victim of persecution by people who are not like you.
“A house divided against itself cannot stand,” Lincoln said channeling Mark 3:25 and Matthew 12:25. America is certainly a house divided. It is a bad omen.
Serbia needs to get on the right side of history
Saša Janković, runner-up at the latest Presidential elections in the Republic of Serbia (2017), writes in Danas:
Serbian President Aleksandar Vučić has made an unnecessary and inappropriate personal gamble with national interests, participating in a campaign of one candidate in the US presidential elections. To make the case even worse, his candidate lost. This is not the first time he has made this mistake. But unlike when he supported Hillary Clinton, this time the consequences will be severe. This was the drop that flooded the cup and his actions will affect the whole country negatively.
At the recent hearing of the American House Committee on Foreign Affairs, likely perspectives of the new American policy towards the Western Balkans were heard. Serbia – or more accurately put – the kind of influence it exercises in the region was defined as a problem. The new American administration will no longer tolerate Serbia making trouble in Bosnia, Kosovo, Montenegro, North Macedonia… nor anywhere else in the Region.
If and when Vučić loses support from Washington, he will have no other shield to hide behind – he has wasted them all already.
The U-turn away from the EU (to which, in fact, he never aspired) will now, unlike previously, hit back. The EU and US are beginning to coordinate their foreign policies again and Washington will not continue compensating for heavy messages from Brussels, as in the previous years. The revival of US – EU cooperation effectively closes the space for Vučić to continue manipulating them against each other.
As for the Russian Federation, Maria Zakharova’s public (and close to vulgar) mockery of the Vučić’s overall position in the Washington agreement (the infamous “Sharon Stone tweet”), revealed Moscow’s attitude towards his troubles. If the Kremlin interferes in the Region, it is in pursuit of Russian interests, not Vučić’s, nor Serbia’s.
Finally, China: if anyone believed Vučić when he claimed (including on billboards throughout Belgrade) that Xi Jinping is his “brother” and will shower Serbia with investments, flying cars, weaponry and protection of all kinds, then we deserve whatever is thrown at us, don’t we?
It is no secret anymore that changes are being considered to the Dayton Agreements. Both entities, including Republika Srpska, could easily lose the position of “state within a state.” That status, which could have been used constructively and as an advantage, Serbian and Croatian political leaders (ab)used as a rope around the neck of Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH). Bosniak leaders didn’t help either, constantly playing victims.
The outcome? A quarter of a century after the war, the citizens of BiH do not have a functional state. Instead, the region has a continuing challenge, despite the lies of politicians from Serbia and Croatia that, as guarantors of the Dayton Agreement, they will support the integrity and sovereignty of BiH. In the meantime, Serbs in Bosnia developed very strong feelings for Republika Srpska.
Republika Srpska is not its most powerful and visible politician, Milorad Dodik. But Dodik, in cooperation with the authorities from Belgrade, ruined the opportunity for the Serbian entity to be constructive and favored by the world. After Vučić has lost his latest gamble, if and when the structure of BiH is changed the question is how much of Republika Srpska’s jurisdiction will remain. He broke so many promises that many in the West have become determined not to let him continue fooling them.
Another challenge, its solution long overdue, is Kosovo. The US and the EU will now insist, without further delay, on a comprehensive agreement between Belgrade and Pristina. Serbia should actively influence its content with its proposals, but Vučić’s populist regime abstains so that it can decline any responsibility for the outcome and blame it on others. His oppressed political opposition acts the same way.
There was just one proposal from the side of the opposition that didn’t include formal recognition of independence and still had some chance to be considered internationally.* It was swiftly declared treasonous by both the Vučić’s regime and the rest of the opposition. Since then, three years ago, neither the regime nor the opposition has proposed what to do.
Instead, some opposition leaders consider that putting forward a proposal would provide Vučić with an opportunity to blame them for the loss of Kosovo, using his propaganda machine. And he would, the record shows. So they choose to wait for the West to force Vučić into making a move, so that they can accuse him of treason and topple him. In the meantime, they join him in inspiring cheap nationalist feelings, needed to help their plan – which in fact mirrors his own.
Other opposition leaders silently agree with Vučić’s tactics of blackmailing everybody, inside and out, with Kosovo and Republika Srpska, with a faint view of the “Greater Serbia” somewhere down the road. They would only do it “faster, stronger, better” (an electoral slogan of Vučić’s own party).
The ultimate result is that the agreement on Kosovo will be written by foreign diplomats, without a substantive role of Serbia. Vučić’s regime and the opposition (with lesser responsibility but in an equal manner) are depriving Serbia of influence on the decision that deeply concerns national interests.
The US and the EU, of course, know that changes in BiH and Kosovo are high-risk operations. They will not make the mistake of conducting them without first weakening those who, for fear of losing their power, can sabotage changes by lighting fires in the region. Therefore the first cracks in the grandiose Vučić’s media image outside and inside of Serbia begin to appear. Cracks begin to show in Vučić’s own party, too – Nebojša Stefanović (for years, Vučić’s most trusted aide) is doing what Vučić, advised and used to do in the extremist Serbian Radical Party before he split it with other dissidents to establish the Serbian Progressive Party. Surely, Vučić recognizes the scenario, working against him now.
No injustice inflicted there on Vučić – what brought him up will pull him down. But the citizens of Serbia will suffer – Vučić’s party captured their state and will leave it in scraps. Not only economically, institutionally and legally, but also emotionally – he deprived the nation of self-respect and hope. Furthermore, Vučić will probably not behave like Kosovo’s Thaci and resign from the presidential post to avoid dragging his country into the dirt. No matter how hard one tries to differentiate between Vučić’s regime and Serbia, when he gets under more serious international criticism and, possibly, restrictive measures, that will not be possible.
So, in the world’s eyes, Serbia will once again be seen as a source of problems and a nation that, for the second time in only two decades, allowed a destructive autocrat to gain a position of unlimited power. Not yet fully recovered from the scars left by Milosevic, Serbia will get new ones. From a symbol of freedom, anti-fascism, vitality and capacity to stand united with South Slavic peoples in a strong and prosperous alliance, to a powerless, excommunicated, humiliated and problematic country that has lost its sense of direction and lags behind – the picture will be daunting and generations of Serbians will carry its shadow as a burden. No one can harm Serbian national interests as Serbian nationalists can.
There is a better way. Serbia should identify itself within the trinity of 1) universal human and civil values, 2) positive elements of our national identity, and 3) Western political culture. We are first human beings and free individuals, citizens with dignity and responsibilities to ourselves and the world we live in. Then we are the Serbs – a freedom-loving, friendly, and brave Slavic nation. Finally, we firmly belong to the civilization of Western democracies!
Saint Sava pointed Serbian religion (and partly spirituality) to the East, towards our Orthodox Slavic brothers. But his brother Stefan, the first crowned ruler of Serbia, not accidentally and not without an agreement with his brother, firmly oriented the Serbian state towards the West. In 1217 he sought and received the first Serbian crown from the Pope, not from the Patriarch in the East (which was an option at the time). Such are the foundations of our identity, which is still the direction for our progress. Every detour costs us lost generations and underdevelopment. Shortcomings of Western democracy, which we speak of constantly as “sour grapes,” we can improve upon only after we master its basics. We must work honestly and never again look for shortcuts. Long live Serbia!
*The proposal included the following:
1. Serbia agrees with (and in fact actively supports) the membership of Kosovo in all international organizations, including the UN. Serbia will not ask for any restrictions or create any obstacles for Kosovo to fully avail itself of every right, obligation, or interest arising from such membership. This attitude of Serbia does not mean and can not be used as proof that it formally recognizes the independence of Kosovo, nor Serbia will be conditioned in any way to do so.
2. The sites of the Serbian Orthodox Church of major historical and religious importance (the key monasteries and churches) shall be given extraterritorial status and left to be self-governed by the Church authorities (similar to the examples of monasteries in Mount Athos in Greece, or the Vatican in Rome).
3. Local self-governance in North Mitrovica and the Association of Serbian Municipalities shall be established, not to be used to the detriment of the authority of Pristina over the whole territory of Kosovo.
4. Individual and collective human rights of Serbs shall be guaranteed at the highest level.
5. Property rights shall be guaranteed in line with international norms and standards.
6. The Agreement shall be valid for 30 years. If before the expiry of that term a new one is not reached, it shall be automatically prolonged for the next 30 years, and so on.
Stevenson’s army, January 6
Election specialists say both Democrats won in Georgia, giving Democrats control of Congress. Stacey Abrams takes a bow.
Looking for a job with Biden? The new Plum Book lists political jobs.
Subcabinet nominees in State include Wendy Sherman and Jon Finer.
IC officials formally blame Russia for recent hack. Amy Zegart cautions against overreacting to it.
Just before adjournment, Congress passed a new foreign aid bill for Eastern Europe.
Dozens of democracy activists arrested in Hong Kong.
Rand study says US military pay is too high.
My SAIS colleague Charlie Stevenson distributes this almost daily news digest of foreign/defense/national security policy to “Stevenson’s army” via Googlegroups. I plan to republish here. To get Stevenson’s army by email, send a blank email (no subject or text in the body) to stevensons-army+subscribe@googlegroups.com. You’ll get an email confirming your join request. Click “Join This Group” and follow the instructions to join. Once you have joined, you can adjust your email delivery preferences (if you want every email or a digest of the emails).
Free at last, by a hair, with work to do
The outcomes of the two Georgia Senate run-off races run yesterday are dramatic. Democrat Raphael Warnock has won by a hair. Democrat Jon Ossoff is leading with mostly mailed-in absentee ballots, which generally favor the Democrats, remaining to count. The Democrats appear certain to take control of the Senate in addition to the House of Representatives and the White House, enabling Joe Biden to pursue what he promised during the electoral campaign with vigor. The Grim Reaper, aka Mitch McConnell, will lose the capacity to block anything he disikes from reaching the floor of the Senate.
At home, this will mean many things: Trump’s populist ethnic nationalist racism will be discredited, the Republican party may have to retool in a more truly conservative direction, democracy will be able to show that it can govern effectively, and Biden or Kamala Harris can hope to campaign in 2024 with a record of success behind them. Health care, energy, education, income taxes, and many other areas will be opened to reform. There is also the real possibility of terrorist violence by Trump supporters, whose more extremist wing will be gathering today in Washington to protest the certification of the presidential election result in Congress.
The Georgia race had nothing at all to do with international affairs, but its ramifications are significant also abroad. The United States has demonstrated that it could recover from ethnonationalist populism by democratic means. Other countries may follow suit: Hungary? Poland? Israel? Serbia? India? None of their would-be nationalist autocrats are delivering results for their countries’ economies and fights against Covid-19 much better than Trump did in the US. And they all start, as Trump did, down by the percentage of minorities who won’t vote for them. While each country has its own political dynamics, the global tide may have turned.
Also important: Democratic control of the House and Senate will enable Biden to try to defeat Covid-19 and restore the economy without being blocked at every turn by current Senate Majority Leader McConnell. Biden aims to vaccinate 100 million Americans in his first 100 days (which will be mid-April). The vaccine rollout so far has been much slower. The economy, which has recovered about halfway from the depths of the epidemic, is now faltering. The Democrats will use control of Congress to fund both a stronger vaccination effort and payments to lower income people and small businesses as well as safer reopening of schools. If by summer the US is back to steadier economic growth and herd immunity is reached, Biden will be a hero at home and far stronger abroad.
Today though will be devoted not to celebrating the Georgia victory but to defeating Republican attempts to change the electoral votes as they are reported to the Congress. The normally pro forma process will be lengthy and contentious as the certified results from some “battleground” states are debated and voted on. But in the end, the Congress will acknowledge Biden’s victory, removing the final hurdle to his inauguration January 20. We are free at last, by a hair, but with lots of work to do.