Categories: Daniel Serwer

Wrong and wrong, maybe wrong again?

I can’t think of anyone who deserves this less.

I could of course be wrong again. But that’s the gloomy picture I am seeing on the day after an election gone wrong.

I was 100% wrong about the outcome of this election. I expected Harris to win the battleground states. She lost them. I expected her to win the popular vote by a wide margin. It’s not yet clear, but it appears she lost it.

I should have known better

I spent the last week in deep red Hall County, Georgia, doing “voter protection” for the Georgia Democratic Party. That entails monitoring paper ballot processing as well as helping adjudicate ambiguously marked ballots. I also duplicated a few dozen so that the scanner can read them. This is done in cooperation with Republicans and County election officials. Yesterday I was a poll watcher in a precinct whose voters include both a retirement community and mostly Mexican immigrants. The electoral mechanism both in the county government center and at the polling place was professional, efficient, and thus boring.

The demographics were more interesting. Hall is a county of more than 42,000 people that depends heavily on two industries. Chickens are first. Medicine is second. Both industries use large numbers of Mexican immigrants. There are not many native-born Americans feeding and slaughtering the chickens or tending the bed pans. Nor I imagine would you get on well doing construction, another thriving sector, if you didn’t speak Spanish.

By the time I got to the polling center yesterday about 11 am the early rush was over. Mid-day belonged mainly to the retirees, many of whom looked like they were patrons of the medical center. The late afternoon saw a rush of mostly younger Mexican Americans. A young US-born Mexican American poll worker provided translation whenever needed. I observed no tension of any sort between the two demographics. The mostly retired poll workers were impeccably correct and helpful to the immigrants, all of whom were US citizens. I hope they all recognized the symbiosis between the two communities.

My precinct voted more than 60% for Trump. Symbiosis doesn’t extend to the ballot box. I have no doubt about where most of the Trump and Harris votes came from.

It’s identity politics

Trump has found a way to make voting for him a question of identity. His racist dog whistles were vital to his first election. His macho man displays are vital to this second, as they shifted male votes in his direction. I find both difficult to understand, as I don’t regard white, male identity as anything more than an arbitrary classification. You could just as well call me short and old, with much more physical evidence to back the claim. I’m not proud of being white, male, short, or old.

I am proud of being an American. To me, that means having lots of individual rights and collective responsibilities. During my lifetime, I have seen the rights expanded. Younger people, Blacks, Latinos, women, and LGBTQ Americans now enjoy far more freedom than they did in my 1950s childhood. It seems to me the responsibility of white males to adjust to those changes. “All men are created equal” is not ambiguous (even if it should now read “all people”). “Make America Great Again” is a slogan that appeals to those who want to return to segregated, male-dominated, heterosexual America. I don’t share that aspiration.

I expect Trump to try to fulfill many of his promises. He made them to cater to interest groups that own him. He will try to deport large numbers of undocumented immigrants and end asylum. As President, Trump will impose more tariffs, raising the cost of living and inducing retaliation by other countries. He will fire large numbers of civil servants. His allies in Congress will try to end abortion country-wide and repeal Obamacare. They will give more tax relief to the rich and burden the middle class. Trump will welcome cryptocurrencies and try to manipulate the Federal Reserve, undermining monetary stability. His Supreme Court nominees will be people prepared to adjust their jurisprudence to his policy preferences.

I could be wrong again

As bad as I think the re-election of Trump is for America, I fear it is worse for the world. Trump will do at least some of what he has promised. We will see an end to American support for Ukraine and surrender of part of it to Putin. That will encourage Russia to try again in Moldova or the Baltics. He will withdraw American troops from South Korea and Japan, encouraging them to get their own nuclear weapons.

The Balkans, which concern many of my readers, will not be top priority. But Trump’s re-election will encourage ethnonationalists throughout the region. If Ukraine is partitioned, why shouldn’t Serbia to try to capture northern Kosovo and Republika Srpska? Why shouldn’t Kosovo join Albania? Washington might even help. War will be a real possibility. Ethnic cleansing and state collapse will follow. All the while, the Trump family will be benefiting financially from Jared Kushner’s Saudi-financed investments in Serbia and Albania.

In the Middle East, Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu will get Trump’s full support. The new Trump Administration will not restrain Israel in Gaza, the West Bank, or Lebanon. Trump will likely encourage military confrontation with Iran. That is the only option left to deter Iran from getting nuclear weapons. Trump will try to get the Saudis to recognize Israel. They will string him along. It remains to be seen whether they will accept Netanyahu’s “less than a state” for Palestine. That proposition is essentially the continuation of the status quo: one state with unequal rights. It is what many call “apartheid.”

I could of course be wrong again. But this is the gloomy picture I am seeing on the day after an election gone wrong.

Daniel Serwer

View Comments

  • A majority of the voters clearly preferred the devil they knew than the angel they didn’t know anything about.

    Remember when many were worried if something happened to Biden? Most were not excited by Harris. Then, when the Dems’ mea culpa screamed out during the infamous debate, Harris got coronated without the benefit of a typical party electoral process. Contrary to media spin, she was not well thought of to that point.

    The Democrats should never have allowed Biden to run. They should have held him strictly to his “caretaker” promise of 4 years. There were plenty of apparatchiks who knew he wasn’t capable of another 4; as such, a non-incumbent set of primaries would have vetted multiple candidates, including giving Harris more time to be recognized and understood. Had she thus won the candidacy that way, I bet she might have beaten Trump.

    Think about it: Hillary lost by just a few votes largely because she avoided campaigning in some key battleground states (particularly PA, and much less Comey’s last minute "revelations"). Harris then campaigns A LOT in all 7 battleground states, and fails to carry any of them.

    That's the message from North Carolina; there the voters elected all Democrats and then crowned Trump. They voted what they knew, not what they couldn’t figure out.

    Harris has great qualities, but you don’t win a national election by treating every speech as a pep rally – especially when the electorate doesn’t know much about you in the first place. It just isn't enough.

    As for the health of the country: hold your hats. To those in hyper worry mode, suddenly the filibuster isn’t looking so bad; the House race is undecided (though trending Republican); there are some Cheney style Republicans in Congress who may prove helpful; and the courts still work. Sorry, but even the current SCOTUS has been known to rule sanely (Roe aside), and did so in a few election cases leading up to Nov 5.

    We have checks and balances. That said, I’d worry a lot less about Trump and a lot more about his being replaced by Vance should Trump not last.

    Now THAT’s worth a worry, though the same checks and balances are extant for him as Trump.

Share
Published by
Daniel Serwer

Recent Posts

Trump’s first foreign policy failure

China will want to assert sovereignty over Taiwan. Israel will annex the West Bank and…

2 days ago

Group rights encourage tyranny

Power should flow from the choices of individuals, organized how they prefer. Forcing people into…

3 days ago

Trump’s cabinet of horrors

This is a cabinet of horrors. Its distinguishing characteristics are unquestioning loyalty to Donald Trump,…

1 week ago

Immigration is clear, national security not

Trump is getting through the process quickly and cleanly. There are lots of rumors, but…

1 week ago

Americans, welcome to the 4th Reich!

I, therefore conclude with a line from the Monk TV series. I may be wrong,…

1 week ago

Requiem for the world order

We acted reluctantly and too late against Germany and Japan. We are likely to be…

2 weeks ago