peacefare.net

The end is nigh, again!

I made a bunch of predictions a year ago.  Here is how they turned out:

• Iran:  the biggest headache of the year to come. If its nuclear program is not slowed or stopped, things are going to get tense.  Both Israel and the U.S. have preferred sanctions, covert action and diplomatic pressure to military action.  If no agreement is reached on enrichment, that might change by the end of 2011.  No Green Revolution, the clerics hang on, using the Revolutionary Guards to defend the revolution (duh).  I wasn’t far off on this one.  No Green Revolution, no military action yet.
• Pakistan:  it isn’t getting better and it could well get worse.  The security forces don’t like the way the civilians aren’t handling things, and the civilians are in perpetual crisis.  Look for increased internal tension, but no Army takeover, and some success in American efforts to get more action against AQ and the Taliban inside Pakistan.  Judging from a report in the New York Times, we may not always be pleased with the methods the Pakistanis use.  It got worse, as suggested.  No I did not anticipate the killing of Osama bin Laden, or the increased tensions with the U.S., but otherwise I had at least some of it right:  growing internal tension, no Army takeover, some American success.
• North Korea:  no migraine, but pesky nonetheless, and South Korea is a lot less quiescent than it used to be.  Pretty good odds on some sort of military action during the year, but the South and the Americans will try to avoid the nightmare of a devastating artillery barrage against Seoul.  I did not predict the death of Kim Jong Il, but otherwise I got it right.  There was military action during the year, but no artillery barrage against Seoul.
• Afghanistan:  sure there will be military progress, enough to allow at least a minimal withdrawal from a handful of provinces by July.  But it is hard to see how Karzai becomes much more legitimate or effective.  There is a lot of heavy lifting to do before provincial government is improved, but by the end of the year we might see some serious progress in that direction, again in a handful of provinces.  This is pretty much on the mark.
• Iraq:  no one expects much good of this government, which is large, unwieldy and fragmented.  But just for this reason, I expect Maliki to get away with continuing to govern more or less on his own, relying on different parts of his awkward coalition on different issues.  The big unknown:  can Baghdad settle, or finesse, the disputes over territory with Erbil (Kurdistan)?  I did not anticipate the break between Maliki and Iraqiyya, but I pegged Maliki’s intentions correctly.  The Arab/Kurdish disputes are still unsettled.
• Palestine/Israel (no meaning in the order–I try to alternate):  Palestine gets more recognitions, Israel builds more settlements, the Americans offer a detailed settlement, both sides resist but agree to go to high level talks where the Americans try to impose.  That fails and Israel continues in the direction of establishing a one-state solution with Arabs as second class citizens.  My secular Zionist ancestors turn in their graves.  Wrong so far as I know about the Americans offering a detailed settlement, even if Obama’s “land swaps” went a few inches in that direction.  Right about failure and Israel’s unfortunate direction.
• Egypt:  trouble.  Succession plans founder as the legitimacy of the parliament is challenged in the streets and courts.  Mubarak hangs on, but the uncertainties grow.  Pretty good for late December, though I was happily wrong about Mubarak hanging on.
• Haiti:  Not clear whether the presidential runoff will be held January 16, but things are going to improve, at least until next summer’s hurricanes.  Just for that reason there will be more instability as Haitians begin to tussle over the improvements.  Presidential election was held and things have improved.  Haiti has been calmer than anticipated.  Good news.
• Al Qaeda:  the franchise model is working well, so no need to recentralize.  They will keep on trying for a score in the U.S. and will likely succeed at some, I hope non-spectacular, level.  Happy to be wrong here too:  they did not succeed, but they did try several times.  And they did not recentralize.
• Yemen/Somalia:  Yemen is on the brink and will likely go over it, if not in 2011 soon thereafter.  Somalia will start back from hell, with increasing stability in some regions and continuing conflict in others.  Yemen has pretty much gone over the brink, and parts of Somalia are on their way back.  Pretty much on the mark.
• Sudan:  the independence referendum passes.  Khartoum and Juba reach enough of an agreement on outstanding issues to allow implementation in July, but border problems (including Abyei) and South/South violence grow into a real threat.  Darfur deteriorates as the rebels emulate the South and Khartoum takes its frustrations out on the poor souls.  Close to the mark, though Darfur has not deteriorated as much as I anticipated, yet.
• Lebanon:  the Special Tribunal finally delivers its indictments.  Everyone yawns and stretches, having agreed to ignore them.  Four indictments were delivered against Hizbollah officials.  I was also right about yawning and stretching.
• Syria:  Damascus finally realizes that it is time to reach an agreement with Israel.  The Israelis decide to go ahead with it, thus relieving pressure to stop settlements and deal seriously with the Palestinians.  Dead wrong on both counts.
• Ivory Coast:  the French finally find the first class tickets for Gbagbo and his entourage, who go to some place that does not recognize the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court (no, not the U.S.!).  The French and UN settled it by force of arms instead of the first-class ticket.  Not cheaper, but less long-term trouble.
• Zimbabwe:  Mugabe is pressing for quick adoption of his new constitution and elections in 2011, catching the opposition off balance.  If he succeeds, the place continues to go to hell in a handbasket.  If he fails, it will still be some time before it heads in the other direction.  He failed and the predicted delay ensued.
• Balkans:  Bosnians still stuck on constitutional reform, but Kosovo gets a visa waiver from the EU despite ongoing investigations of organ trafficking.  Right on Bosnia, wrong on Kosovo.

I’m content with the year’s predictions, even if I got some things wrong.  Of course I also missed a lot of interesting developments (revolutions in Tunisia, Libya and Syria, for example).  But you wouldn’t have believed me if I had predicted those things, would you?  Tomorrow I’ll discuss 2012.